Home › Guides › Flavors and Toppings: The Complete Ingredient Guide
🍒 Strategy GuideFlavors and Toppings: The Complete Ingredient Guide
Papa's Bakeria has six filling flavors and six toppings, and every order combines them in new ways. Here is the full ingredient list and the mix-ups that trip up new bakers.
The six fillings
Apple, Cherry, Chocolate, Strawberry, Lemon, and Pumpkin. Each has its own color that appears in your pie as you pour — red for cherry, yellow for lemon, orange for pumpkin, and so on. The color preview is a handy way to confirm you picked the right one.
The six toppings
Cream, Cherry, Almonds, Sprinkles, Banana, and Grapes. Every order asks for exactly two, and the topping grid lets you select exactly two — tap a selected topping again to unselect it if you change your mind.
Watch the cherry trap
Cherry exists as both a filling and a topping. An order might want cherry filling with banana and grapes on top — no cherry topping at all. Slow down when you see the word cherry anywhere in an order.
Half credit is real
Toppings are scored individually at 10 points each. If you are unsure about one topping, getting the other one right still earns you half the topping points, so never leave the pie bare.
