Home › Guides › How to Earn 3 Stars on Every Pie
⭐ Strategy GuideHow to Earn 3 Stars on Every Pie
Stars are the report card at the end of every pie. Here is exactly how they are earned and where your attention matters most.
The star thresholds
Your pie is scored out of 100: crust 20, flavor 20, filling accuracy 20, bake timing 20, and toppings 20. Score 90 or more for three stars, 65+ for two stars, 40+ for one star. Below that, you get a heartbreak — and a very sad customer.
Lock in the free 60
Crust, flavor, and toppings require zero skill — only careful reading. That is 60 points available just for matching the order. Never donate these points to rushing; the timer-free order screen means you can read as slowly as you like.
The skill 40
Filling and baking are the two skill checks. If you consistently land both, three stars become routine. If one is shaky, remember both give partial credit for near misses — a slightly overfilled pie with perfect everything else can still hit 90+.
Chase the perfect bonus
A flawless 100-point pie earns a bonus 25 coins on top. Over a five-customer day, perfect pies versus two-star pies is the difference between a good day and a Master Baker day.
